Permaculture Wizard›Blog›Design
Map your winter shade in November before you plant anything
November is the best month to find out where your garden is actually dark. Not where you think it's dark. Where it is. The leaves are coming off, the sun is low, and every shadow on your land is longer than it was in June by a factor of four or five. If you plan beds, a greenhouse or a fruit tree from your memory of summer, you are planning for a sun that won't be there half the year. I've done it. The rhubarb was happy. Nothing else was.
So here's the job for this week: one sunny afternoon, a tape measure, a notebook, and about two hours.
How low is the November sun in Switzerland, Germany and Austria?
Low. At solar noon, the sun's height above the horizon is roughly 90° minus your latitude plus the sun's declination for that day. I ran the numbers for a few cities using that standard formula (you can check any spot with the NOAA Solar Calculator or SunCalc):
- Zurich (47.4° N): about 26° at noon in early November, 19° at the winter solstice, 66° in late June.
- Munich and Vienna (48.1–48.2° N): about 26° now, 18° at the solstice, 65° in June.
- Berlin (52.5° N): about 21° now, just 14° at the solstice, 61° in June.
That's the highest the sun gets all day. Morning and afternoon, it's lower still. Valleys and north-facing slopes lose more, because the hill on the other side becomes your horizon.
How long are winter shadows, and why should you care?
Shadow length is the object's height divided by the tangent of the sun's angle. Translated into garden language:
- In Zurich or Vienna today, a 2 m hedge throws a noon shadow of about 4 m. On 21 December it's about 6 m.
- In Berlin on 21 December, that same hedge throws about 8 m. Four times its own height.
- In late June in Zurich, the same hedge casts under 1 m.
That's why the bed that looks perfect in July sits in shade from October to March. It's also why your neighbour's 10 m spruce matters far more than your own 1.5 m currant bushes. A 10 m tree at Zurich's solstice noon shades almost 29 m of ground behind it. That's most small gardens.
Why care? Because the things that need winter light are exactly the things people put in the wrong place: a greenhouse or cold frame for overwintering salads, a sitting spot, a south wall for espaliered fruit, solar panels, and the bed where garlic and broad beans are meant to wake up early in March.
How do you map your sun and shade this week?
Pick a clear day. Do this, in this order:
- Find true south. A compass app is good enough, since magnetic north in Central Europe is only a few degrees off true north. Or note where the sun stands at solar noon, which in early November is around 12:10 in Zurich and 11:40 in Vienna on standard time.
- Mark shadows three times. At about 10:00, 12:30 and 14:30, walk the edge of every shadow on the ground and push in a stick or drop a stone. Different colours for each time if you're fancy. I use whatever's in my pocket.
- Draw it. A rough plan on paper, or a printout from a map. Shade the area that stays dark at all three times. That's your winter shade zone.
- Measure the big stuff. Height of house, hedges, trees and the neighbour's garage. Rough is fine: pace out the shadow and do the maths later.
- Photograph from the spots that matter. Stand where the greenhouse might go and take a photo south. Whatever blocks the sky in that photo is your problem.
If it's foggy for weeks, which in the Swiss Mittelland is entirely possible, you can still sketch it from the numbers above and confirm on the first clear day.
What do you do with the shade you find?
Don't panic. Shade isn't bad. Shade in the wrong place is bad.
- Put the winter-light stuff in the bright strip. Cold frames, greenhouse, early beds, the bench you'll actually use in February.
- Give the deep winter shade to plants that don't care. Anything that grows mainly in summer when the sun is high is fine there: many perennial herbs, currants and gooseberries, which tolerate part shade, compost bays and the woodpile.
- Remember deciduous trees are winter windows. A walnut or apple shades in summer and lets most light through from November to April. Evergreens like spruce, thuja and cherry laurel block it year-round. If you're planting a new hedge on the south side, that difference decides whether your garden is dark for five months or not.
- Plan heights from south to north. Low stuff on the south side, tall stuff on the north. The oldest rule in the book, and still ignored by half the plans I see.
What about trees near the boundary?
If the shade comes from next door, or if you're about to plant something that will shade next door, check the rules before you dig. They are cantonal in Switzerland and set by each German state, and they change.
- Canton Zurich: since 1 December 2024, forest trees and large ornamental trees need 4 m from the boundary, field fruit trees and smaller ornamental trees 2 m, and shrubs 50 cm, all measured from the middle of the trunk, according to § 169–170 EG ZGB as summarised by Haus-Forum.ch and the Naturnetz Pfannenstil update. Older leaflets still show the previous 8 m and 4 m figures, so check the date.
- Other cantons differ a lot. The same Haus-Forum table lists 5 m in Bern and 6 m in Lucerne, Aargau and St. Gallen for large non-fruit trees.
- Bavaria: plants up to 2 m tall need 0.5 m from the boundary, anything taller needs 2 m, under Art. 47 AGBGB. The Bavarian justice ministry's garden boundary brochure explains how it's measured.
- Austria and the other German states have their own rules. Ask your municipality.
Notice something: none of these distances is anywhere near the 29 m shadow of a big tree in December. The law keeps the peace. It doesn't keep your light. Talk to your neighbour before either of you plants something tall on the south side.
FAQ
Can I do this mapping in summer instead?
You can, but you'll map the wrong garden. Summer shadows are short and trees are in leaf, so you'll overestimate winter light. Do it between now and February, ideally once more near the solstice.
Do I need special tools?
No. A compass app, a tape measure, some sticks and paper are enough. Online sun calculators help you check sun angles and sunrise and sunset directions for any date.
My garden faces north. Is it hopeless?
No. You'll grow more in summer than in winter, and you'll lean on shade-tolerant fruit, perennials and summer crops. The map tells you which corners still get winter sun, and there's usually one.
Should I cut down a tree that shades the garden?
Not before you've mapped it. A deciduous tree might shade you only when the sun is high anyway. Check local tree protection rules first, too.
Map your shadows now, and then check what else your land is telling you at Permaculture Wizard's site check.
boundary rulessectorssite readingsun and shadewinter